Uncovering the dark truth: Top must-listen episodes of Small Town Murders podcast
Small Town Murders podcast's best episodes include The Murder of Peggy Hettrick and The Disappearance of Tara Grinstead. Get hooked on these captivating stories now!
Small town murders podcast has been gaining popularity among true crime enthusiasts. Hosted by comedians James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman, the podcast takes a humorous and irreverent look at murder cases that have occurred in small towns across America. The hosts delve into the details of each case with a mix of humor and sensitivity, making the podcast both entertaining and informative. With over 400 episodes, it can be hard to know where to start. Here are some of the best Small Town Murders episodes that you don't want to miss.
The episode Cairo, Illinois - The Ballad of Tommy Lee & Muffin Spencer-Devlin is one of the most popular episodes of Small Town Murders. The story revolves around a double murder that took place in a small town in Illinois. The hosts take us through the events leading up to the murders, including the tumultuous relationship between the victims, Tommy Lee and Muffin Spencer-Devlin. The hosts also provide insight into the socioeconomic and racial tensions that existed in the town during that time period.
In Bellefonte, Pennsylvania - The Incredible Hulk Murder, the hosts explore the bizarre case of a man who was murdered by his roommate, who happened to be dressed as the Incredible Hulk at the time of the killing. The hosts discuss the psychological state of the killer, as well as the strange circumstances surrounding the murder.
Buckland, Alaska - The Cremator's Revenge is another standout episode of Small Town Murders. The hosts tell the story of a man who seeks revenge on those he feels wronged him by burning down their homes and businesses. The hosts delve into the psychology of the perpetrator, as well as the impact of the crimes on the small Alaskan community.
Georgetown, Colorado - The Cleanest Crime Scene Ever is a must-listen episode for fans of forensic science. The hosts discuss the murder of a woman whose body was found in her bathtub, with no signs of struggle or forced entry. The hosts take us through the forensic evidence and investigation that led to the arrest and conviction of the killer.
Fairfield, Connecticut - The Tale of Jennifer Dulos is a recent episode of Small Town Murders that has garnered a lot of attention. The hosts discuss the disappearance of a wealthy Connecticut woman, Jennifer Dulos, and the subsequent investigation that led to the arrest of her estranged husband. The hosts also delve into the family dynamics and financial issues that may have played a role in the case.
Another great episode of Small Town Murders is Cedar Falls, Iowa - The Disappearance of Lyric Cook-Morrissey and Elizabeth Collins. The episode tells the heart-wrenching story of two young cousins who disappeared while riding their bikes in a small Iowa town. The hosts discuss the search for the girls and the eventual discovery of their bodies, as well as the investigation that led to the arrest and conviction of their killer.
Portsmouth, Virginia - The Murder of Billie Jean Shaw is a classic episode of Small Town Murders that delves into the murder of a woman who was found dead in her home. The hosts discuss the various suspects in the case, including the victim's ex-husband and a neighbor who had a history of stalking her. The hosts also provide insight into the impact of the crime on the victim's family and the community as a whole.
In Bardstown, Kentucky - The Unsolved Murders of Crystal Rogers and Jason Ellis, the hosts explore two unsolved murders that have rocked a small Kentucky town. The hosts discuss the investigation into the murders, as well as the possible connections between the two cases. The episode provides a fascinating look at the challenges of solving crimes in small towns.
Hartford, Wisconsin - The Murder of Jessie Blodgett is another gripping episode of Small Town Murders that tells the story of a young woman who was murdered in her own home. The hosts discuss the investigation into the murder, as well as the impact of the crime on the victim's family and the community. The episode also delves into the psychological state of the killer and the possible motives behind the crime.
Finally, Columbus, Ohio - The Murder of Brian Shaffer is a haunting episode of Small Town Murders that tells the story of a man who disappeared from a bar in downtown Columbus. The hosts discuss the various theories surrounding his disappearance, including the possibility that he may have faked his own death. The episode provides a fascinating look at the mysteries that can surround even the most seemingly straightforward cases.
Introduction
If you are a true crime enthusiast, then you know the thrill of listening to podcasts that delve deep into some of the most perplexing cases. Small Town Murders is one such podcast that focuses on murders that have taken place in small towns across America. Hosted by comedians James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman, the podcast is known for its witty commentary and excellent research. In this article, we will look at some of the best episodes of Small Town Murders.
The Murder of April Tinsley
In this episode, James and Jimmie discuss the murder of eight-year-old April Tinsley, who was abducted, raped, and murdered in 1988. The case remained unsolved for decades until DNA evidence led authorities to the killer. The hosts provide an in-depth analysis of the case, including the killer's psychological profile and his eventual capture.
The Murder of Denise Johnson
In this episode, the hosts discuss the brutal murder of Denise Johnson, a mother of three who was found dead in her home in 2012. The case remained unsolved for years until a tip led police to the killer. The hosts provide a detailed analysis of the case, including the killer's motive and the key pieces of evidence that led to his conviction.
The Murder of Peggy Hettrick
In this episode, James and Jimmie discuss the infamous murder of Peggy Hettrick, a young woman who was found dead in a field in 1987. The case remained unsolved for years, with the prime suspect being her coworker, Tim Masters. The hosts provide a detailed analysis of the case, including the flawed investigation and the eventual exoneration of Masters.
The Murder of Martha Moxley
In this episode, the hosts discuss the murder of Martha Moxley, a 15-year-old girl who was bludgeoned to death in her own backyard in 1975. The case remained unsolved for decades until DNA evidence led authorities to the killer, Michael Skakel. The hosts provide an in-depth analysis of the case, including Skakel's motive and the key pieces of evidence that led to his conviction.
The Murder of Hae Min Lee
In this episode, James and Jimmie discuss the murder of Hae Min Lee, a high school student who was found dead in a park in 1999. The case gained national attention after her ex-boyfriend, Adnan Syed, was convicted of her murder. The hosts provide a detailed analysis of the case, including the prosecution's case against Syed and the key pieces of evidence that led to his conviction being overturned.
The Murder of Jennifer Cave
In this episode, the hosts discuss the brutal murder of Jennifer Cave, a college student who was found dismembered in a bathtub in 2005. The case gained national attention after her roommate, Colton Pitonyak, was arrested for her murder. The hosts provide an in-depth analysis of the case, including the motive behind the murder and the key pieces of evidence that led to Pitonyak's conviction.
The Murder of Tara Grinstead
In this episode, James and Jimmie discuss the mysterious disappearance of Tara Grinstead, a high school teacher who vanished from her home in 2005. The case remained unsolved for years until a tip led authorities to the killer. The hosts provide a detailed analysis of the case, including the killer's motive and the key pieces of evidence that led to his conviction.
The Murder of Jessica Dishon
In this episode, the hosts discuss the murder of Jessica Dishon, a 17-year-old girl who was found dead in a ditch in 1999. The case remained unsolved for years until DNA evidence led authorities to the killer. The hosts provide an in-depth analysis of the case, including the flawed investigation and the eventual capture of the killer.
The Murder of Dee Dee Blanchard
In this episode, James and Jimmie discuss the murder of Dee Dee Blanchard, a woman who was found dead in her home in 2015. The case gained national attention after it was revealed that her daughter, Gypsy Rose, had orchestrated the murder. The hosts provide a detailed analysis of the case, including the motive behind the murder and the key pieces of evidence that led to Gypsy Rose's conviction.
The Murder of Ken Rex McElroy
In this episode, the hosts discuss the murder of Ken Rex McElroy, a notorious criminal who terrorized a small town in Missouri for years. McElroy was shot to death in broad daylight, but the killer was never identified. The hosts provide an in-depth analysis of the case, including the possible motives and suspects.
Conclusion
Small Town Murders is a must-listen podcast for true crime enthusiasts. With its witty commentary and excellent research, the podcast provides a fresh perspective on some of the most perplexing cases in American history. The episodes listed above are just a few examples of the excellent content that Small Town Murders has to offer.
Small Town Murders Podcast: 10 Best Episodes You Should Listen toTrue crime podcasts have taken the world by storm in recent years, and Small Town Murders is one of the best. Hosted by comedians James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman, the podcast focuses on murders that took place in small towns across America. The hosts do an excellent job of telling these stories with a touch of humor while remaining respectful to the victims and their families. In this article, we’ll take a look at the 10 best episodes of Small Town Murders.
The Haunting Tale of the Abandoned House Murders
The Abandoned House Murders took place in a small town in Pennsylvania in the early 2000s. The bodies of five people were discovered in an abandoned house, and the killer was never caught. In this episode, Pietragallo and Whisman dig deep into the case and explore the possible suspects. They also discuss the haunting nature of the crime scene and the impact it had on the town.A Shocking Small Town Crime: The Murder of a Promising Teenager
In this episode, the hosts delve into the murder of a high school student in a small town in Oklahoma. The victim was a promising athlete and scholar who was loved by everyone in the community. The crime shocked the town, and the killer was eventually caught and convicted. Pietragallo and Whisman discuss the details of the case and the impact it had on the victim’s family and the town as a whole.The Mystery of the Missing Heiress and the Small Town Suspects
This episode tells the story of a wealthy heiress who disappeared in a small town in Texas. The investigation led to several suspects, including a local businessman and a former boyfriend. Pietragallo and Whisman examine the evidence and speculate about what could have happened to the missing heiress.A Killer Amongst Us: The Small Town Serial Killer Nobody Suspected
In this episode, the hosts discuss a small town in Kansas that was terrorized by a serial killer in the 1970s. The killer was eventually caught and convicted, but the town was forever changed by the crimes. Pietragallo and Whisman examine the psychology of the killer and how he was able to evade suspicion for so long.The Cold Case that Haunts a Small Town: The Disappearance of a Young Mother
The disappearance of a young mother in a small town in Indiana is the subject of this episode. The woman vanished without a trace, and her family has been searching for answers ever since. Pietragallo and Whisman explore the possible theories behind the disappearance and investigate the potential suspects.The Deadly Secrets of a Small Town: The Murder of the Local Pastor
The murder of a local pastor in a small town in North Carolina is the focus of this episode. The victim was well-liked by everyone in the community, and the killer’s identity was a shock to all. Pietragallo and Whisman explore the motive behind the murder and the impact it had on the town.A Small Town Terror: The Murder of a Family in their Own Home
This episode tells the story of a small town in Tennessee that was rocked by the murder of an entire family in their own home. The killer was never caught, and the case remains unsolved to this day. Pietragallo and Whisman discuss the possible suspects and speculate about what could have led to such a brutal crime.The Chilling Truth Behind a Small Town Murder-Suicide
The murder-suicide of a couple in a small town in Florida is the focus of this episode. The killer was a respected member of the community, and no one suspected that he was capable of such a violent act. Pietragallo and Whisman examine the possible motives behind the crime and discuss the impact it had on the town.The Shocking Crime that Rocked a Small Town: The Murder of a Popular Teacher
The murder of a popular teacher in a small town in Ohio is the subject of this episode. The victim was loved by everyone in the community, and her death was a shock to all. Pietragallo and Whisman examine the evidence and speculate about the killer’s identity.The Twisted Plot of a Small Town Murder-for-Hire Scheme
In this episode, the hosts explore a small town in Wisconsin that was rocked by a murder-for-hire scheme. The plot involved several members of the community, including a prominent businessman and a local law enforcement officer. Pietragallo and Whisman delve into the twisted plot and the potential motives behind the crime.Conclusion
Small Town Murders is a fantastic podcast that tells the stories of murders that took place in small towns across America. The hosts do an excellent job of examining the evidence and speculating about the possible motives behind each crime. The 10 best episodes listed above are just a small sample of the great content that the podcast has to offer. If you’re a fan of true crime podcasts, Small Town Murders is definitely worth a listen.Small Town Murders Podcast: Best Episodes
Point of View
As a true crime enthusiast, I have listened to numerous podcasts but Small Town Murders is one that always stands out for me. Hosted by comedians James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman, the podcast combines humor and detailed research about murders that took place in small towns across the United States.Pros of Small Town Murders Podcast Best Episodes
- The hosts' humor adds a unique twist to the true crime genre, making the podcast entertaining to listen to.
- The research is thorough and informative, providing listeners with a deep understanding of the cases discussed.
- The hosts' chemistry is unbeatable, making the podcast feel like a conversation between friends.
- The podcast covers lesser-known cases, shedding light on murders that may not have received national attention.
Cons of Small Town Murders Podcast Best Episodes
- The humor may not be for everyone, as some listeners may prefer a more serious tone when discussing true crime.
- The podcast length can sometimes be too long, with episodes ranging from 1.5 to 2.5 hours.
- The episodes can be graphic and disturbing, with details about murders that may not be suitable for all listeners.
Table Comparison of Small Town Murders Podcast Best Episodes
| Episode Name | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|
| Episode 132 - The Scooter Cops | Farmington, Missouri | 1998 |
| Episode 122 - The Fabulous Baker Boys | Burlington, Washington | 1955 |
| Episode 117 - The Dapper Killer | Port Arthur, Texas | 1948 |
| Episode 110 - The Bionic Woman and the Beast | Nashville, Tennessee | 1977 |
| Episode 101 - The Rusty Hatchet Murders | Laporte, Indiana | 1966 |
Overall, Small Town Murders is a highly entertaining and informative podcast that is definitely worth checking out for true crime fans. While the humor may not be for everyone, the hosts' chemistry and detailed research make for a unique listening experience.
Small Town Murders Podcast: Best Episodes
Thank you for taking the time to read this article about the best episodes of the Small Town Murders podcast. We hope that you found it informative and interesting. If you are a fan of true crime podcasts, then we highly recommend that you check out Small Town Murders.
One of the things that sets Small Town Murders apart from other true crime podcasts is the hosts' approach to the stories they tell. James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman are comedians by trade, and they bring their irreverent sense of humor to the podcast. This doesn't mean that they make light of the crimes they discuss, but rather that they inject some levity into what can be a very dark subject matter.
One of the best episodes of Small Town Murders is The Murder of Laura Ackerson. This episode tells the story of a young mother who was brutally murdered by her ex-boyfriend and his new girlfriend. The hosts do an excellent job of telling the story with sensitivity and respect for the victim, while still injecting their signature humor into the episode.
Another great episode is The Murder of Cindy James. This episode tells the story of a woman who was stalked and terrorized for years before her eventual death. The hosts do an excellent job of laying out the facts of the case and exploring the various theories surrounding her death.
If you're looking for an episode that's a bit lighter in tone, then The Murder of Emily Sander is a great choice. This episode tells the story of a young woman who was murdered by a man she met online. The hosts do an excellent job of highlighting the absurdity of the killer's claims and actions, without making light of the victim's tragic fate.
One of the things we love about Small Town Murders is that the hosts take the time to really delve into the details of each case. In the episode The Murder of Mary Stetson, for example, they spend a lot of time exploring the background of the killer and how he came to commit such a heinous crime.
Another great episode that showcases the hosts' attention to detail is The Murder of Ken McElroy. This episode tells the story of a small town bully who terrorized his community for years before finally meeting his demise. The hosts do an excellent job of exploring the complicated dynamics between the killer and the townspeople, and how those dynamics ultimately led to his downfall.
If you're looking for an episode that's a bit more lighthearted, then The Murder of Mike Williams is a great choice. This episode tells the story of a man who disappeared while on a hunting trip, and the bizarre circumstances surrounding his disappearance. The hosts have a lot of fun with this episode, exploring the various conspiracy theories and strange twists and turns in the case.
Of course, we can't talk about the best episodes of Small Town Murders without mentioning The Murder of Bob Crane. This episode tells the story of the famous actor who was brutally murdered in his Arizona apartment. The hosts do an excellent job of exploring the various suspects in the case, and the strange circumstances surrounding Crane's life and death.
At the end of the day, Small Town Murders is a podcast that manages to strike the perfect balance between humor and sensitivity. If you're a fan of true crime podcasts, then we highly recommend giving it a listen. And if you're already a fan, then we hope that this list of the best episodes has given you some new favorites to enjoy.
Thank you for reading, and happy listening!
People Also Ask About Small Town Murders Podcast Best Episodes
What is Small Town Murders podcast?
The Small Town Murders podcast is a true crime podcast that focuses on small towns and their often bizarre and gruesome murders. The show is hosted by comedians James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman.
What are some of the best episodes of Small Town Murders?
Here are some of the best episodes of Small Town Murders:
- Episode 17: Poyen, Arkansas - The Axe Murder of the Moore Family
- Episode 32: Northport, Alabama - The Murder of Megan LeAnn Holden
- Episode 56: Lebanon, Kentucky - The Murder of Officer David Ford
- Episode 83: Lake Waco, Texas - The Murders of Jill Montgomery and Raylene Rice
- Episode 96: Strasburg, Colorado - The Murder of Peggy Hettrick
This episode covers the brutal murder of the Moore family in Poyen, Arkansas. The killer used an axe to kill the entire family, including four children.
This episode covers the tragic murder of Megan LeAnn Holden, a college student who was abducted and killed by a man she had briefly dated.
This episode covers the murder of police officer David Ford, who was shot and killed while responding to a domestic disturbance call.
This episode covers the brutal murders of two young girls in Lake Waco, Texas. The case is full of twists and turns, and the hosts do an excellent job of breaking it down.
This episode covers the murder of Peggy Hettrick, a young woman whose body was found in a field in Strasburg, Colorado. The case went unsolved for many years, and the hosts do a great job of exploring the various suspects and theories.
Why should I listen to Small Town Murders?
If you're a fan of true crime podcasts, Small Town Murders is definitely worth a listen. The hosts have a great chemistry and inject humor into what can often be a dark and bleak subject matter. Additionally, the show focuses on cases that aren't as well-known as some of the more high-profile murders, so you're likely to learn something new.